Opinion: Safeguarding lawyers and defendants
December 19, 2012 | BY
clpstaff &clp articles &The amended Lawyers Law better protects the rights of lawyers and defendants by expanding what constitutes confidential information and brings the law in line with the Criminal Procedure Law
The amended PRC Lawyers Law (中华人民共和国律师法) clearly states that a lawyer is entitled to serve as a defender during a criminal investigation and it expands their rights during these investigations – for example, the rights of investigation and to take evidence. The procedural rights of the suspects or defendants are also highlighted in the amendment, ensuring they are strictly protected. This change is in line with the PRC Criminal Procedure Law (中华人民共和国刑事诉讼法), which was amended in March 2012.
The main reason the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress (NPC) amended the Law is to bring it in line with the Criminal Procedure Law. Inconsistencies between the two laws led to different understandings in practice, which may have affected the legitimate rights of the criminal suspect. It is because of these inconsistencies that the Standing Committee accordingly amended the Law to maintain the unity of legal system and to ensure the effective implementation of both pieces of legislation.
|Ethics and responsibilities
To bring the Lawyer's Law in line with international standards, the scope of confidential information during the practice of law has been expanded. “The facts and information regarding a crime that seriously endangers the safety of property of other people which the client or other person is preparing to commit or is committing,” are now included in the scope of confidential information (Article 38).
To solve the barrier between social disputes and protect the fundamental rights of citizens, the Law imposes strict requirements on legal ethics in the practice of law by lawyers. While a lawyer is exercising the rights duly authorised by their client after they have been retained or authorised through legal procedures and are therefore fully able to handle a variety of legal issues, the lawyer assumes certain responsibilities, which includes the responsibilities under the laws, like the confidentiality obligation and property safety obligation.
The Lawyers Law clarifies the rights and obligations of lawyers and clients, which ultimately better serves judicial justice. The Law shares many commonalities with similar legislation in other countries, but still retains some unique factors. The similarities lie in the provisions that provide clear legal status and set out the rights of lawyers, which protect the procedural and other lawful rights and interests of a criminal suspect or defendant. The differences are that China's Lawyers Law has its own characteristics, which are decided by the country's situation regarding economy, society, politics and culture and the legal system, especially considering the changes to the Criminal Procedure Law. We cannot simply conclude which legislations is better, but should judge whether it fulfils the legislative purpose under specific social realities and legal systems.
The amended Lawyers Law is also expected to better standardise the behaviours of lawyers in practice and to lead to greater predictability in the system. We believe that the amendments to the Law make a great improvement in this regard. We are looking forward to the results of the amended Law as it is now aligned with the Criminal Procedure Law and that the lawyers' rights can gradually expand. Needless to say, the amendments have already achieved this expectation to some extent.
Huang Zhimin, Guantao Law Firm, Beijing
This premium content is reserved for
China Law & Practice Subscribers.
A Premium Subscription Provides:
- A database of over 3,000 essential documents including key PRC legislation translated into English
- A choice of newsletters to alert you to changes affecting your business including sector specific updates
- Premium access to the mobile optimized site for timely analysis that guides you through China's ever-changing business environment
Already a subscriber? Log In Now